This question is from a friend of mine, who reads my blog. And I figured I'd post my "answer" here, so that maybe others could maybe...
Ah whatever.
"Hey- so
quick question since you write about this stuff in blogs and all---if i
still don't have enough for a great reel--what would you suggest doing?
Seems lame to do one of those actors access slates--not really into
that idea personally. Isn't it better to wait and have a reel with kick ass scenes than a mediocre one where I'm not featured as well or the quality of the film is so-so? -- That was a bit long-winded."
Love the question... I'm not sure I'll give you the answer you'll want to hear, because as you know everything is subjective in this business. Everything... And this is just an opinion.
Here's a quick story before I start...
In New York I had several friends that studied and sang opera... They all had "good" voices, some had better natural gifts than others, some had more technique then others, but most were out there auditioning. Even some with "small, but ugly voices." Whether or not they were auditioning before their time, I'm not sure, and who's to say really... But this story is about one particular friend who had a very large voice... Beautiful voice.... A very open voice... She had been training for years before I met her... Went to college for voice... Had voice teacher after voice teacher... All the time I lived down the block from her... She studied... She was never "ready" to audition... She had to develop... Had to build... Had to something or learn something...
Now, she would sing for friends at the drop of a hat... Called herself an opera singer... Wanted a career in opera as a singer... But she never auditioned... She was never "ready." I moved out of New York City... She continued to train... Eventually she got married... Had a child... Moved a thousand miles away from New York... All the while... TRAINING... I don't talk to her too often any more as life gets busy, and distance creates distance... But, I believe she's still tripping to NYC several times a year for lessons, as well as training locally. And I believe she still believes she's not "ready." Maybe she's right... But as she ages her voice changes... As she ages her looks change... And as she ages... She's still not singing opera professionally.
I would imagine most of us jump the gun some times, I know I did with singing a decade ago in New York it beat me up and spit me out, and I know I've tanked a few auditions in a few rooms, where the people casting will never see me again for any acting part... But that happens... Hey there's that whole Clint Eastwood and Burt Renolds story right?
This from IMDB... "He (Clint Eastwood) was a contract player at Universal International. He and another young actor named Burt Reynolds
were released from their contracts and left the studio on the same day.
They were both fired by the same director. Eastwood was fired when the
director didn't want to use him in a movie because "his Adam's Apple
was too big." Reynolds, who was serving as a stunt man, was fired after
he shoved the director into a water tank during an argument over how to
do a stunt fall."
The truth is for 95% of us, our reels can always be better or more current... 95% of us could say "it's not good enough" or "we need to keep training" for the rest of our lives. At some point we have to say... "This is what I have done." "This is my voice." "This is my work."
The other truth is... People wanted to see my reel only when I had nothing on my resume... Once I got guest star credit after guest star credit on my resume... NO ONE seemed to care to see my reel any longer. It's like once they know you have "good" tape, they stop asking for it.
To answer your question, as I suppose Agents looking at new talent need to see something... And getting them to a play is ridiculous, and having them sit there for 120 minutes to see you do one character, isn't really a "good" usage of their "free" time.
So, here's my advice... Have someone who knows how to edit decide if the material is usable or not... A good editor may be able to make a CO-star role shine, or cut a crappy scene in a crappy student film into a solid scene by creatively using what's already there. I edited someone's reel a few weeks ago, and while she had some okay stuff, we both believe I was able to make it much, much more solid.
Now if your material are all one liners... Or you're on camera for half of each line you say... Or it's mostly out of focus... Yeah, that might not show you off very well, and you should wait.
One solution is of course doing MORE films, MORE freebies... Another solution is what a few friends of mine have done and that's SHOOTING mini-scenes... Either with other friends or with classes or with these little production companies that offer such services.... However, my advice on those mini-scenes... Make them look and sound like actually movies... And not like they've been shot for the purposes of a reel... They're just like the middle of a scene that really has no beginning or end to it.
This whole one minute reel thing is a semi-blessing for someone like you... If you have 30 guest star roles, you can only cut so many parts in that 60 seconds. And you can only hold on one scene for at most 60 seconds... And if you want to show some "range..." Four clips at 15 seconds each... Three clips of 20 seconds each... The days of the 5 minute reel are LONG GONE...
Well, if you look at your stuff again, or get someone that "knows" what can be cut and how, you might very well find 3 twenty second clips of "good" usable material. And you just have that, then you just have that.
-- Just My Quichepinon ~ Tom Kiesche